Jyrk, I will complain! You always use the timeline "after 1900" in your questions, so I found Charles Smith but how I belived the timeline "after 1900" was active I put him on garbbard. In my opinion you should rethink it.
Because of poor record keeping prior to 1900, it's hard to say exactly how many Long had, but I looked up some of the reference sites that I use, and Baseball Reference has him credited with 122 errors (117 at SS, 5 at 2B) and 60 RBI. That would tie him with Smith .I'll give you the points as well.